Saturday 4th of May 2024

what about me .....

what about me .....

Government by haircut. Who'd have thought it? In the four years since Kristina Keneally felt impelled to assure Parliament she had "never worn a pair of stilettos" she has achieved a far far greater thing, to which many strive but few finally attain: ascension by hair.

I realised this recently after yet another Kristina-tract landed on our stoop. You know the format. Me with awestruck old people, me with people in wheelchairs, me with grinning black kids, me cycling, me hugging the homeless. And I'm having a one-more-shot-of-Keneally's-blowdried-coif-and-I-throw-up moment when it strikes me who she's channelling.

Perhaps it's the combination of hair and throwing up that triggers my epiphany, since the glowing figure at its centre is the soi-disant bulimic Princess Di.

It's the same stuff. Not quite up there in performance terms, but the same lip-gloss insouciance, the same doe-eyed "I'd like to be a queen of people's hearts" deep-lens look, the same flicky blonde hair.

The same relentless public empathy, as though just feeling for people will change the world.

Keneally makes much of her good deeds, but there is a touch of facadism about it. Like last week's enormous hoo-ha about rejecting the Bickham coal mine (that just happened to be opposed by Alan Jones, Gerry Harvey, Phillip Adams and Bob Hawke) having already approved some 30-odd new or expanded coalmines in her 14 months as planning minister and doubled Port Kembla's coal terminal capacity.

Like opening the new St Vinnies mental health building with Cardinal George Pell, while presiding over a state where parents of mentally ill or disabled children live increasingly in terror of what will happen to their children when they can no longer provide full-time care.

Like her huge display of welcoming the Pope on World Youth Day, backed up by public nuisance legislation to make Stalin proud.

I'm amazed that we tolerate this stuff. And, though I try to ignore it, my pattern recognition button bleeps red, suggesting parallels with our extraordinary tolerance of the Catholic Church's child abuse.

Child abuse is evil not just because it involves sex with children, although I'd certainly hesitate before trusting my kids to the too-tender hands of any priest, frocked or not.

It's not just the cover-up, the knowing protection and perpetuation of these crimes, nor the cruel hypocrisy of the church's response.

The worst evil of child abuse as inflicted by God's agent is the napalming of the child's sense of goodness. Children's moral sense is intense but fragile. For any moral figure - doctor, father, teacher, but especially priest - to prove instead an active source of harm is profoundly destructive.

But for this harm to be inflicted repeatedly in the name of love, and under the public cloak of goodness, throws that child into outer space, with no idea of what good or love might mean and - worse - no capacity for trust.

For the church then to compound this damage by deliberately trivialising its crimes as the minor fallings from grace of ordinary humans and treating their victims as dramatisers is truly stomach-turning.

It staggers me that we so much as tolerate the church's "you go to the police, we won't pay" line, much less throw city-wide parties for its visiting chieftain and impose totalitarian restrictions to that end.

If any other corporation tried it - a child-care company, say - they would be flogged without mercy.

They'd be given the David Campbell treatment.

Which brings me to Keneally's performance on television last Friday. Campbell's long sexual secret was, she kept repeating, appalling, distressing. She paused, unsatisfied, seeking the right word. Then she continued. It was "in fact unforgivable that he lived with a secret''.

Unforgivable. The Premier's use of the word was considered and deliberate. As irony would have it, however, she was scheduled to address the Writers' Festival the next morning on the same subject, forgiveness.

My, what a bind. She could hardly bowl up and spruik the idea that hiding things from the public was unforgivable. Just think. They'd all have to resign. So she took the political option. She recanted. Suddenly "it was not unforgivable, what he did".

But either it was or it wasn't. If it was, she should have stuck with her condemnation. If not - if, as most of us think, Campbell's secret was a private infraction deserving private resolution - Keneally and her cabinet should have stood by him, refusing his resignation and telling the media to get lost. But to accept his resignation, connive at his destruction and then forgive him as Christian kindness is hypocrisy of the most self-serving kind.

What's really unforgivable, though, is this. Campbell has been one of the worst transport ministers in a government famed for its uselessness. Successive bunglings have included the Iron Cove bridge fiasco, the CBD Metro and the F3 tailback, any one of which should have produced his sacking. But he's been held in place by Sussex Street's numbers machine.

As Keneally said, "his resignation has nothing to do with his performance of his job".

So what did the resignation have to do with? With keeping her clean. The guilty are feted and the innocent(-ish) thrown to the dogs.

Kristina Kenneally Like Princess Di

 

short back & sides .....

Kristina Keneally's premiership has hit crisis point after the resignation of two ministers within hours, throwing her government into chaos two weeks before the Penrith byelection and four days before the budget.

After days of publicly defending her minister for state development, Ian Macdonald, against charges he had used taxpayers' money to fund an overseas trip, Ms Keneally cut him loose yesterday, making him the 12th minister to go of the 22 who were sworn in after the 2007 election.

At a news conference last night, Ms Keneally announced Mr Macdonald resigned after admitting "errors made in his travel arrangements for the trip he took to Dubai in 2008".

"The minister assured me everything was in order," she said. "The minister today admitted there were errors made."

She said Mr Macdonald "has apologised unreservedly", despite him not appearing at the news conference.

However, she refused to release the details of the errors, including whether they were travel or accommodation costs or the amounts involved, before the completion of an internal government review of Mr Macdonald's trip that was ordered on Wednesday.

She promised to release the review when it is completed in about a week.

Only hours earlier, Ms Keneally had suffered a sharp rebuke from her close friend, the juvenile justice minister, Graham West, who resigned amid revelations that he had learnt a tender for a juvenile justice program had been cancelled by the Department of Commerce without his knowledge two weeks ago.

His timing is being read as a deliberately hostile act, after cabinet last month rejected the recommendations of a landmark report he commissioned into juvenile justice.

Keneally in crisis

and mike carlton's take .....

At long last there are encouraging signs that the state government is getting its act together. The exciting new policy of showering favours and buckets of money on multi-millionaire horse breeders in the Hunter Valley is a great leap forward and a surefire election winner.

As the Herald reported last week, the government is believed to be offering as much as $160 million - plus another $50 million in loans - to fund a shotgun marriage for Sydney's two race clubs, the Australian Jockey Club and the Sydney Turf Club.

This will be music to the ears of the stud owners and their media friends who, as everyone knows, have been battling along on the smell of an oily rag for years, never sure where their next million is coming from. And that's not all. There's been the recent $2 million upgrade for the airport at Scone, and the decision to block plans for an open-cut coalmine in the valley, helpfully announced on the day of the Scone Cup last month.

And it doesn't stop with horseracing. We've also had the wonderful news of $45 million of taxpayers' money to be pumped into the V8 Supercar race at Homebush Bay over the next five years, $10 million more than was originally set aside for this globally admired project.

Of course there will be the narks and whingers. We will hear endless complaints from the do-gooders - people caring for the disabled or the mentally ill, mothers working two jobs to afford childcare, single parents in rundown public housing, elderly folk waiting years for hip replacement surgery, and so on.

This special pleading should be ignored. For too long Labor governments have been obsessed with supporting grassroots battlers. It's high time the rich and powerful were properly looked after.

This new direction appears to be a joint effort by Kristina Keneally and her Minister for Lunching, Ian Macdonald. They are worth every airline upgrade they are offered, and more.